The importance of Voluntary Carbon Markets
A growing consensus has developed regarding the need for a global, scalable Voluntary Carbon Market that can deliver a rigorous, market-based approach for investment in activities that reduce greenhouse gas emissions and remove carbon from our atmosphere. This would enable companies and investors to confidently build upon their net zero transition strategies by financing activities elsewhere that address their remaining emissions whilst on the journey to zero (credibly defined, using Science-based Targets). Doing so will increase the likelihood of avoiding catastrophic climate change, reducing our collective risk and securing a more prosperous future for all. Given the volume of climate mitigation activity that will take place in the Global South, this also provides a key financing tool for those countries in a just transition.
Voluntary Carbon Credits are a proven mechanism for this finance – each credit represents one tonne of CO2 (or equivalent greenhouse gas) reduced or removed that has been independently verified against robust accounting methodologies. However, issuing carbon credits as a source of finance is only possible if they derive from projects that would not be undertaken as ‘business as usual’ or via commercial investment – a concept known as ‘additionality’ i.e. the activity is genuinely additive to the sum total of existing global efforts to reduce CO2.
This creates a ‘chicken and egg problem’ – how do you develop a liquid market through which to finance genuinely additive projects without having an existing deep and liquid market? By facilitating the listing of instruments that deploy capital at scale into climate mitigation projects, the London Stock Exchange will contribute to global efforts to address this problem.
The current Voluntary Carbon Market ecosystem has evolved over 20 years and features credible standards bodies, supported by international NGOs and used by experts in private-sector and non-profit companies to finance climate mitigation projects. It has become increasingly professionalised, but it remains small and fragmented, and as such it lacks the market infrastructure and access to institutional investment that will truly enable it to scale.
The growth in companies that are making commitments to meeting net zero targets by positive action and off-setting strategies for residual risk is being stifled by the combination of a largely OTC procurement model from small entities and rapidly rising secondary market prices for a limited pool of quality carbon credits.
With the creation of a capital markets solution for financing projects that enhance investment in carbon mitigation projects, the London Stock Exchange believes that it can directly address at least two major barriers: capital at scale for the development of new climate projects worldwide and primary market access to a long-term supply of high-quality carbon credits for corporates and other investors. This will also support the market’s broader efforts to deliver investment-grade data and commercial innovation.
How will the new Voluntary Carbon Markets solution work?
In order for funds to be listed, we expect to use the London Stock Exchange’s existing market infrastructure, supplemented by specific requirements relevant to carbon credit projects (starting with the high-level definitions from the Taskforce on Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets (TSVCM) and ultimately incorporating their approach into the London Stock Exchange admission requirements[2]). We envisage these vehicles being structured in a way that will enable their investors to receive investment returns in specie, in the form of carbon credits, instead of, or in addition to, cash dividends and other distributions. The process of generating carbon credits will use the current ecosystem of standards and verification bodies that is being strengthened by the efforts of the TSVCM, supported by industry experts and civil society groups. In this way, as the TSVCM work on areas the Core Carbon Principles develops, we will build upon what works well today, whilst enabling climate action at scale.
We anticipate that corporates and other investors with long-term needs for carbon credits will be the key investors who will use the output of these vehicles to meet a portion of their needs, possibly investing in multiple funds to spread risk and build a diversified portfolio, which may be supplemented and hedged in the secondary market. Because of the framework we will create, these investors will have the comfort of knowing that their investment will be going directly into climate action on the ground. In turn, this will create the confidence and liquidity needed for institutional investors to participate. Project developers can focus on their core expertise and climate projects around the world, particularly in the Global South, will benefit from access to capital flows that are currently small and inconsistent.